Insight

Founding engineer vs agency: when each makes sense

Early-stage founders often face a choice: hire a founding engineer (or work with a founding engineer pod) versus engaging an agency. This is an objective comparison of tradeoffs, not a sales pitch. Both models work—the question is which fits your stage, constraints, and goals.

Written by Aravind Srinivas, early engineer at Rupa Health and Founder & CEO of HyperNest Labs. This article reflects public information and operator perspective—no speculation on confidential details.

What is a founding engineer (or founding engineer pod)?

A founding engineer operates like an early employee: they own product surfaces end-to-end, write documentation, mentor juniors, and participate in roadmap decisions. They join your Slack, attend standups, and feel like part of the team—not an external vendor.

A founding engineer pod (like HyperNest Labs) provides a small team of senior ICs plus a tech lead who can act as fractional CTO. The pod embeds directly in your rituals and tooling, shipping features that feel indistinguishable from in-house work.

Key characteristics:

  • Direct access to senior operators (no account managers)
  • Ownership of entire feature areas, not just tickets
  • Participation in architecture and hiring decisions
  • Flexible engagement (can scale up or down quickly)
  • Often priced per engineer or per pod, not hourly

What is an agency model?

Agencies typically provide project-based or retainer-based services with clear scopes, deliverables, and timelines. They often have specialized teams (design, frontend, backend, QA) and can handle larger, well-defined projects.

Key characteristics:

  • Account managers or PMs coordinate between you and the team
  • Clear project scopes with defined deliverables
  • Specialized teams for different parts of the stack
  • Often better for one-off projects or specific features
  • Typically priced per project or monthly retainer

When founding engineers make sense

You're in 0→1 or 1→10 phase:

When you need someone who can own ambiguous scopes, make architecture decisions, and ship features that evolve with customer feedback. Founding engineers excel at building the first version of something, not just implementing a spec.

You need to hire your first 5–10 engineers:

Founding engineers can help design hiring loops, interview candidates, and onboard new hires into a clean codebase. They transition knowledge smoothly when you're ready to bring everything in-house.

You want embedded partnership, not handoffs:

If you need someone who joins investor calls, updates board docs, and co-owns outcomes—not just delivers features and moves on.

Examples: Rupa Health (fractional CTO during scaling), Earn Life (founding pod for 0→1), EatCookJoy (rebuild after cyberattack).

When agencies make sense

You have a well-defined project with clear scope:

Agencies excel when you can write a detailed spec, set a budget, and expect predictable deliverables. Think: "Build a mobile app for iOS and Android with these 12 screens" rather than "Help us figure out what our product should be."

You need specialized skills for a short period:

If you need a dedicated design team, QA specialists, or mobile developers for a specific project, agencies can provide that specialization without long-term commitment.

You have an internal team that can manage the relationship:

Agencies work best when you have a PM or tech lead who can write clear specs, review deliverables, and coordinate handoffs. If you don't have that capacity, the agency model can create more overhead than value.

Hybrid approaches (and when they work)

Many successful startups use both models at different stages:

  • Founding engineers for core product: Use a founding engineer pod to build your 0→1 product and establish architecture, then hire your first full-time team.
  • Agency for one-off projects: Use an agency for specific features (mobile app, design system, marketing site) while your founding engineers focus on core product.
  • Founding engineers + agency specialists: Have founding engineers own architecture and product decisions, while an agency handles specialized work (e.g., mobile, design) under their guidance.

The key is clarity: founding engineers own strategy and core product; agencies own well-scoped deliverables.

Related reading